These figures are reportedly exclusive to the 2023 Advent Calendar.
 |
| Bears - Justin Fields |
 |
| Bengals - Joe Burrow |
 |
| Bills - Josh Allen |
 |
| Broncos - Russell Wilson |
 |
| Browns - Myles Garrett |
 |
| Chargers - Justin Herbert |
 |
| Commanders - Chase Young |
 |
| Cowboys - Micah Parsons |
 |
| Cowboys - Dak Prescott |
 |
| Dolphins - Tyreek Hill |
 |
| Eagles - Jalen Hurts |
 |
| Giants - Saquon Barkley |
 |
| Jaguars - Trevor Lawrence |
 |
| Raiders - Davante Adams |
 |
| Rams - Aaron Donald |
 |
| Rams - Cooper Kupp |
 |
| Seahawks - DK Metcalf |
 |
| Steelers - T. J. Watt |
 |
| Titans - Derek Henry |